Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Adam's avatar

I appreciate this is something you'll probably get a lot of comments on, but I've found the QR code page at the end a very unpleasant reading experience. The last thing I want to do when I've finished a book I enjoy is pull out my phone, scan a code and awkwardly squint at the last page on a small screen that I don't even seem to be able to zoom in on. And while I understand the whole point is preventing spoilers so the page goes up at a specific time, as a non-US reader it's a pain that I'm not even able to finish reading the comic I just bought because the final page isn't available yet. As someone who has been annoyed by spoilers before, I'd prefer them over this QR code stuff any day. Hopefully you reconsider for future books

Expand full comment
callie's avatar

Tom, I keep hearing about how the point of this new line of X-Books is meant to have 'something for everyone,' as you felt like Krakoa didn't have wide enough appeal. I'm just wondering if you have any context of the early krakoa era, as it's been said pretty explicitly by JDW/Hickman that the point of the initial krakoa launch was to have at least one book that would appeal to everyone.

Marauders for swashbuckling action and political machinations, X-Men for slice of life stories about characters whose slices of life include aliens and vaults, New Mutants as a book that explores Krakoa as a place people live, excalibur as a fantasy book, and x-force as an espionage book.

Later on, books like Hellions, X-Men v2, Immortal, X-Men Red, Way of X, Sabretooth, and the Fall of X series' continued to keep this in the offings, with there always being a handful of books for every kind of reader. So my question, I guess, is how is this different? I know you're doing a lot of things in this relaunch specifically to address things you thought were problems with the Krakoa era, so I'm wondering if there's something I'm missing that makes this new era any more widely appealing other than the core premise being one less focused on a mutant nation.

Expand full comment
55 more comments...

No posts