Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Fabian Nicieza's avatar

>> Neil Cohen

I was glad when he was brought back for New Warriors but wasn't a fan of Fabian portraying him as more of a meathead instead of the good guy he had been, though I grew to enjoy it. What is your feeling about that switch in character? <<

>>> I tell you, Neil, I had been a regular reader of NOVA at least for its last couple of issues, and I really liked the character. But I also feel as though he was often written as just another generic young good guy without a lot of specific personality to him. So for me, Fabian’s approach , while he maybe steered into it a bit too sharply at first, worked all right in that it helped to make Rich more of an individual and less of a generic type. <<<

Just to clarify something that remains a little vexing to me 30+ years later -- and acknowledging Neil said he grew to enjoy it, but "Novaheads" (as I called the small diehard original-series Nova fans who loudly complained when Nova first reappeared in NEW WARRIORS) consistently acted as if the version of Rich Rider I introduced in New Warriors was taking place five minutes after they had finished reading Nova's last appearance in FF after his series had been cancelled.

For me, it was roughly 2 years later. 2 bad years for Rich. 2 years where he didn't aspire up and all his friends left for college. 2 years where he got wrapped up in a very bro-centric meathead clubbing and weight-lifting scene in Queens. So... he became a meathead.

And starting him out as a meathead was ALWAYS part of a PLAN, because I expected to get his name and costume officially back by issue 12-ish once the trademark/editorial continuity concerns with Frankie Raye lapsed (in light of my confidence that New Warriors' success would blow other claimants out of the water). And even then I knew I would recreate the Nova-corps sometime in the 4th year of the book, so I planned accordingly.

I gave Rich Rider an arc.

In order for him to climb back up he had to start at the bottom.

You can't tell me that if you read New warriors #1-53 and the Nova series I wrote you don't see how the character regained a better perspective on his role and himself.

Did I ever want him to revert COMPLETELY to what I considered slightly-bland Peter Parker-ish clone from the original series? No. I wanted him to grow up with a little more edge. And in my mind, my vision for how I saw his future development WAS fulfilled by the work of Abnett & Lanning during their years spent on the character.

And on another note, when I was editing BARBIE and BARBIE FASHION in the early 90s, both those titles were Marvel's #1-2 in subscriptions, each with 40k+.

My grinding frustration with our subscription department that they didn't spend any $ to try and INCREASE those already solid numbers, I assure you, were not gears that turned in silence. Tom knows I was not smart enough to stay quiet back then... :)

Expand full comment
Steve Cleff's avatar

Really enjoy the newsletter Tom and I read it every week. Hope the joy returns!

Expand full comment
41 more comments...

No posts